Welcome to Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe
At Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe, nestled on Bloomfield Avenue in Caldwell, NJ, a passion for fresh, high-quality seafood shines through. This charming eatery, renowned for its welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, seamlessly blends a seafood market with a cozy dining experience. Customers rave about the exceptional dishes, from perfectly cooked fish to mouthwatering appetizers like fried calamari and coconut shrimp. The BYOB policy adds to its allure, allowing patrons to enjoy their favorite beverages alongside delightful meals. With a menu enriched by local ingredients and a commitment to flavor, Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe is truly a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts.
-
390 Bloomfield Ave Caldwell, NJ 07006 United States Hotline: (973) 226-2031
Nestled on Bloomfield Avenue in Caldwell, NJ, Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe is a hidden gem that perfectly blends the charm of a local seafood market with the welcoming vibe of a casual dining establishment. Known for its commitment to freshness and quality, this seafood haven has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Walking into Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe, you are greeted by a cozy atmosphere, ideal for both families and friends. The restaurant's unique setup offers an array of utilities, including reservations, delivery, takeout, and on-site parking, making it a convenient stop for any seafood lover. Whether you're looking for a quiet dinner or a lively gathering, this place has something for everyone.
Among the standout dishes, the Fried Calamari tossed in a delightful balsamic ginger sauce is a must-try, showcasing how the kitchen elevates simple ingredients into an extraordinary appetizer. For those seeking something a bit more adventurous, the Charred Octopus is grilled to perfection, served with a medley of potatoes and olives that play wonderfully off the tender seafood. Customers rave about the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail and Oysters Rockefeller, both of which exemplify attention to detail and the quality of the catch.
- Soups: The New England Clam Chowder and Lobster Bisque are perfect for warming up chilly evenings, each offering a rich and comforting experience.
- Salads: The Seafood Salad – a vibrant mix of shrimp, calamari, and octopus – is particularly refreshing, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil and herbs that enhance the freshness of the ocean's bounty.
- Main Dishes: The pan-roasted grouper and creative specials like soft shell crabs in scampi style keep the menu exciting and ever-changing, catering to seasoned seafood aficionados.
Moreover, what truly sets Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe apart is the heartfelt service. The staff is known for their friendliness and warmth, with many guests mentioning how welcoming they feel. As one customer pointed out, "The owner/chef comes around to each table to make sure everything is perfect," highlighting the personalized attention that elevates your dining experience.
While the restaurant presents a BYOB option, the presence of an outdoor seating area allows you to enjoy your meal al fresco, adding to the overall experience. With delightful dishes, a casual ambiance, and attentive service, Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe is undoubtedly a keeper in the community, and a place you’ll find yourself returning to time and again.
So, whether you’re craving a comforting bowl of clam chowder or a plate of perfectly grilled snapper, Caldwell Seafood Market & Cafe is where you’ll find excellence on every plate. Don't miss the chance to indulge in an unforgettable seafood experience!
Tiny restaurant in front of seafood store. Waitperson was delightful, patient and helpful. Food was very good: especially the fresh fish perfectly cooked and seasoned. Sides were nothing special; likewise the desserts. Prices very good. Was our first visit and I am looking forward to returning. Is a BYOB which is also nice.
Amazing place. Seafood is SOooo Fresh. Counter Help is generous with kindness and caring!
Food is amazing and super flavorful.. this restaurant was highly recommended by world's greatest Sheriff ..
Great food. A hidden gem. Nice people also. High quality seafood. Tremendous tuna fish. Shrimp and cocktail sauce are noteworthy.
5 stars for food and service. Maybe 3 1/2 stars for value on the Fried seafood platter... but even though the platter was a little expensive for the amount of food, it was *excellent*. Calamari with Fra Diavolo sauce was super. Tender, fresh, seasoned and the sauce was actually spicy. Portion on calamari was very nice. Fried seafood platter was absolutely delicious, just a little weak on the quantity. 2 stellar, giant shrimp, 1 amazing scallop and 2 very small pieces of very tasty breaded fried fish fish (breaded not battered). Every thing we ate was fantastic (literally everything - even the slaw was fresh and delicious). Just wish there was a little more of the seafood platter. Service was friendly and very prompt at lunch. We will definitely be back here.
Four of us had an outstanding seafood dinner. Oysters on the half-shell were exquisite. Delicious lobster roll. Excellent coconut prawns, crab cakes & Cajun-style red snapper. Great coleslaw and best fries I've had in ages. All at an extremely reasonable price, too. This place is a real keeper.
The seafood here was excellent. Everything was fresh. The owner/chef comes around to each table to make sure everything is perfect with his guests. Very good seafood pasta dishes better than many Italian restaurants in the area.
Was going to visit the place next door, but I saw this place and the packed tables so I went in. Boy was I glad! It's a fish market turned restaurant, full of locals who love seafood. It's similar concept to the place in Maywood. BYOB, white table cloth (nice), with a casual feel. Food was well done, and flavorful. I always know by the way kitchen does their whole fish if you they are any good. The Bronzino I got was crisped to near perfect whole skin goodness. Juicy throughout and fresh enough to taste the good waters of Greece (Anthony explained that this was the one fish he gets imported). Just delightful. Next time, have chopsticks ready Anthony (it's easier to eat fish with chopsticks). The side of broccoli rabe was well done. We also got mixed seafood grill which was very tasty. Grilled octopus appetizer was nice. For two of us, we could have ordered less. Lots of food. It's a good comfy neighborhood seafood place that serves great seafood near nyc quality. Prices were reasonable for what we got. We will be back. Support your local businesses!
Anthony has created a enduring menu with some of the best fish & chips in the area his specials are creative especially the beet and burrata salad which is large enough for two to share when in season i throughly enjoy the soft shell crabs scampi style and his snapper livornese is the perfect combination of ingredients you also have the option of raw bar here too for those that indulge in oysters you can't go wrong with any menu item here
We were looking for a new restaurant for dinner this past Saturday and stumbled upon Caldwell seafood market. Was a good choice. Friendly staff n a small gem on Bloomfield Ave. we had the bang bang shrimp and beets and buratta as appetizer. Shrimp was tasty n the beets n buratta had greens, strawberry, mango n a tasty dressing. For entrees we had the pan roasted grouper special in special sauce w mashed potatoes n julienned vegs and red snapper. Both were delicious. Generous Portions n had leftovers to bring home. To top it off we shared a chocolate hazelnut mousse which was to die for. Will certainly stop by another time. R Thank u Caldwell seafood market for a great dinner.